Skip to Main Content
Headshot for Associate Krista Plagge
  1. Krista Plagge, REALTOR ®
  2. Tropic Shores Realty
  3. Mobile: 813.285.1702
  4. krista@homeguidetampa.com
Skip to Main Content
  1. Home
  2. Property Search
  3. Search results
  4. 616 Eaton Street, KEY WEST, FL 33040
616 Eaton Street, KEY WEST, FL 33040
Image Gallery
Property Photos
616 Eaton Street
  1. Image 1 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  2. Image 2 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  3. Image 3 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  4. Image 4 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  5. Image 5 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  6. Image 6 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  7. Image 7 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  8. Image 8 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  9. Image 9 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  10. Image 10 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  11. Image 11 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  12. Image 12 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  13. Image 13 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  14. Image 14 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  15. Image 15 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  16. Image 16 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  17. Image 17 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  18. Image 18 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  19. Image 19 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  20. Image 20 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  21. Image 21 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  22. Image 22 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  23. Image 23 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  24. Image 24 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  25. Image 25 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  26. Image 26 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  27. Image 27 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  28. Image 28 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  29. Image 29 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  30. Image 30 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  31. Image 31 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  32. Image 32 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  33. Image 33 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  34. Image 34 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  35. Image 35 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  36. Image 36 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  37. Image 37 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  38. Image 38 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  39. Image 39 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  40. Image 40 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  41. Image 41 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  42. Image 42 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  43. Image 43 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  44. Image 44 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  45. Image 45 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  46. Image 46 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  47. Image 47 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  48. Image 48 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  49. Image 49 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  50. Image 50 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  51. Image 51 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  52. Image 52 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  53. Image 53 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  54. Image 54 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  55. Image 55 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  56. Image 56 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  57. Image 57 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  58. Image 58 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  59. Image 59 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  60. Image 60 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  61. Image 61 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  62. Image 62 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  63. Image 63 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  64. Image 64 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  65. Image 65 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  66. Image 66 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  67. Image 67 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  68. Image 68 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  69. Image 69 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  70. Image 70 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  71. Image 71 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  72. Image 72 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  73. Image 73 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  74. Image 74 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  75. Image 75 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  76. Image 76 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  77. Image 77 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  78. Image 78 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  79. Image 79 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  80. Image 80 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  81. Image 81 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  82. Image 82 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  83. Image 83 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  84. Image 84 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  85. Image 85 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  86. Image 86 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  87. Image 87 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  88. Image 88 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
View all images
  1. Image 1 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  2. Image 2 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  3. Image 3 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  4. Image 4 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  5. Image 5 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  6. Image 6 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  7. Image 7 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  8. Image 8 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  9. Image 9 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  10. Image 10 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  11. Image 11 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  12. Image 12 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  13. Image 13 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  14. Image 14 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  15. Image 15 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  16. Image 16 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  17. Image 17 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  18. Image 18 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  19. Image 19 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  20. Image 20 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  21. Image 21 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  22. Image 22 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  23. Image 23 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  24. Image 24 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  25. Image 25 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  26. Image 26 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  27. Image 27 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  28. Image 28 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  29. Image 29 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  30. Image 30 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  31. Image 31 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  32. Image 32 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  33. Image 33 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  34. Image 34 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  35. Image 35 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  36. Image 36 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  37. Image 37 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  38. Image 38 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  39. Image 39 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  40. Image 40 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  41. Image 41 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  42. Image 42 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  43. Image 43 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  44. Image 44 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  45. Image 45 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  46. Image 46 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  47. Image 47 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  48. Image 48 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  49. Image 49 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  50. Image 50 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  51. Image 51 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  52. Image 52 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  53. Image 53 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  54. Image 54 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  55. Image 55 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  56. Image 56 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  57. Image 57 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  58. Image 58 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  59. Image 59 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  60. Image 60 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  61. Image 61 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  62. Image 62 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  63. Image 63 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  64. Image 64 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  65. Image 65 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  66. Image 66 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  67. Image 67 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  68. Image 68 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  69. Image 69 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  70. Image 70 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  71. Image 71 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  72. Image 72 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  73. Image 73 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  74. Image 74 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  75. Image 75 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  76. Image 76 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  77. Image 77 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  78. Image 78 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  79. Image 79 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  80. Image 80 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  81. Image 81 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  82. Image 82 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  83. Image 83 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  84. Image 84 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  85. Image 85 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  86. Image 86 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  87. Image 87 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
  88. Image 88 of 88 For 616 Eaton Street
Print Flyer
Contact Krista Plagge
Contacting Krista Plagge
  • All fields are required.
Schedule A Showing
Schedule a Showing.
  • All fields are required.
Check this box to Register with us:
Virtual Tour
More Like This
  • MLS#: 613995 ( Single Family )
  • Street Address: 616 Eaton Street
  • Viewed: 3
  • Price: $7,950,000
  • Price sqft: $3,959
  • Waterfront: No
  • Waterfront Type: None
  • Year Built: 1939
  • Bldg sqft: 2008
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Total Baths: 7
  • Full Baths: 5
  • 1/2 Baths: 2
  • Days On Market: 135
  • Additional Information
  • Geolocation: 24.5578 / -81.8015
  • County: MONROE
  • City: KEY WEST
  • Zipcode: 33040
  • Subdivision: Old Town Unrecord (1.0)
  • Provided by: Truman & Co. (KW)
  • Contact: Terri Spottswood
  • (305) 292-2244
  • Florida Keys Board of REALTORS
  • DMCA Notice
  • Description
    Nestled in the heart of Key West's historic district, 616 Eaton Street is a testament to quality, timeless beauty, and refined living. This single family residence was constructed in 1911 and painstakingly renovated and reimagined over the last few years culminating in 2024 with the spectacular like new home. Most hidden from the Street, it exudes classic Key West architecture blended with modern elegant designs. With 5 bedrooms, 5 full baths & 2 half baths, the home spans 4,000sf on a large 12,478sf lot. The 2 story primary home contains the living room, dining room, kitchen, 2 office spaces/dens, one of which could be a bedroom if desired, 2 half baths on the living level & a spectacular 2nd floor primary suite with office/ laundry & an enormous outside covered deck for private lounging. Thoughtful renovations include a stunning glass wall that opens between the outdoor dining pavilion & the top of the line kitchen w/ functional pass through windows from the kitchen to the pool area. Reclaimed hardwood floors & tall ceilings ensure a perfect balance of historical character & contemporary functionality. The substantial living area, accented by natural light, offers a warm & inviting atmosphere & the gorgeous central pool w/ a water feature creates a stunning outdoor oasis & is perfect for entertaining. Surrounding the pool & outdoor dining pavilion are 2 phenomenal guest houses, housing a total of 4BD/4BA plus a full 1,512sf attic w/ staircase that is built for storage. Lots of off street parking is offered along w/ a carport & small garage. Everything is new, from the hard wood floors & bathrooms to the salt generated heated pool & generator. This property is a rare offering that combines historical significance, luxurious living & an unbeatable location in one of Key West's most coveted neighborhoods. Located in the X flood zone just 2 blocks from both Duval St. & the Historic Seaport, it is walkable to all the wonderful restaurants, galleries & shops.
Request More Information
  • All fields are required.
Property Location and Similar Properties
All
Similar
Features
Waterfront Description
  1. None
Absolute Longitude
  1. 81.80152
Alternate Key Num
  1. 1006432
Appliances
  1. Washer
  2. Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
  3. Wine Cooler
  4. Ice Machine
  5. Gas Appliances
  6. Microwave
  7. Oven
  8. Range
  9. Refrigerator
  10. Dishwasher
  11. Dryer
Association Info 1st Right Of Refusal
  1. No
Association Info Association Fee
  1. 0.00
Association Info Mandatory Home Owners Asc
  1. No
Construction
  1. Frame
Cooling
  1. Central Air
  2. Ductless
  3. Ceiling Fans(s)
Deed Restrictions
  1. Unknown
Dockage
  1. None
Exterior Features
  1. Bar
  2. Water Display
  3. Storage
  4. Privacy Wall/Fence
  5. Lanai
  6. Lighting
  7. Detached Guest Qtrs
  8. Gazebo
Fee Includes
  1. None
Flood Zone
  1. X FLOOD ZONE
Floor
  1. Tile
  2. Wood
Heating
  1. Central
Interior Features
  1. Wet Bar
  2. Quartz Countertops
  3. Built-in Cabinets
  4. Walk-in Closet(s)
  5. Storage
  6. Entrance Foyer
  7. Cathedral Ceilings
Kw Neighborhood
  1. Old Town-N of Truman
Legal Description
  1. KW PT LOTS 1-2-3-4 SQR 36 G56-165/66 OR1251-2426/39 OR1430-1752/55 OR1555-1637/38 OR2582-257/58 OR2699-351/53 OR2703-23
Limitd Reprsntation
  1. No
Mile Marker
  1. 1.00
Min Rental Days
  1. 30.00
Parcel Num
  1. 00006210-000000
Pets
  1. Pets Allowed
Pool Info
  1. In Ground
  2. Decked
  3. Concrete
  4. Salt Water
Pool Info Heated
  1. Yes
Porchbalcony
  1. Open Porch/Balcony
  2. Deck
Property Condition
  1. New Construction
  2. Updated/Remodeled
Property Group Id
  1. 19990816212109142258000000
Property Type
  1. Single Family
Pub Sewer Hkup
  1. Yes
Rentals Allowed
  1. With Restrictions
Roof
  1. Metal Roof
Side
  1. Median
Sqft Source
  1. Property Data Card
Style
  1. Single Family
Tax Year
  1. 2024
Taxes
  1. 24189.10
Total Number Of Units
  1. 0.00
Utilities
  1. FKAA
  2. Propane
  3. Whole House Generatr
  4. Buyer to Verify
  5. Municipal Sewer
Vehicle Storage
  1. Garage
  2. Covered Parking
  3. Off Street Parking
  4. Carport
Vehicle Storage Car S
  1. 4+
Virtual Tour Url
  1. https://www.zillow.com/view-imx/10e83a89-11a5-4d78-ad88-81ec2f65de28?setAttribution=mls&wl=true&initialViewType=pano&utm_source=dashboard
Water View
  1. No Waterview
Windowsdoors
  1. Glass Doors
  2. Impact Rstnce Window
  3. Other Windows/Doors
Year Built
  1. 1939
Zoning
  1. HMDR - Historic Medium Density Residential
Liked Listings
Skip to Main Content
Headshot for Associate Krista Plagge
  1. Krista Plagge, REALTOR ®
  2. Tropic Shores Realty
  3. Mobile: 813.285.1702
  4. krista@homeguidetampa.com