Skip to Main Content
Headshot for Associate Krista Plagge
  1. Krista Plagge, REALTOR ®
  2. Tropic Shores Realty
  3. Mobile: 813.285.1702
  4. krista@homeguidetampa.com
Skip to Main Content
  1. Home
  2. Property Search
  3. Search results
  4. 1231 South Street, KEY WEST, FL 33040
1231 South Street, KEY WEST, FL 33040
Image Gallery
Property Photos
1231 South Street
  1. Image 1 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  2. Image 2 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  3. Image 3 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  4. Image 4 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  5. Image 5 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  6. Image 6 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  7. Image 7 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  8. Image 8 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  9. Image 9 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  10. Image 10 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  11. Image 11 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  12. Image 12 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  13. Image 13 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  14. Image 14 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  15. Image 15 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  16. Image 16 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  17. Image 17 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  18. Image 18 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  19. Image 19 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  20. Image 20 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  21. Image 21 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  22. Image 22 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  23. Image 23 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  24. Image 24 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  25. Image 25 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  26. Image 26 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  27. Image 27 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  28. Image 28 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  29. Image 29 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  30. Image 30 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  31. Image 31 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  32. Image 32 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  33. Image 33 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  34. Image 34 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  35. Image 35 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  36. Image 36 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  37. Image 37 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  38. Image 38 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  39. Image 39 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  40. Image 40 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  41. Image 41 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  42. Image 42 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  43. Image 43 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  44. Image 44 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  45. Image 45 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  46. Image 46 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  47. Image 47 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  48. Image 48 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  49. Image 49 of 49 For 1231 South Street
View all images
  1. Image 1 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  2. Image 2 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  3. Image 3 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  4. Image 4 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  5. Image 5 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  6. Image 6 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  7. Image 7 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  8. Image 8 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  9. Image 9 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  10. Image 10 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  11. Image 11 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  12. Image 12 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  13. Image 13 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  14. Image 14 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  15. Image 15 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  16. Image 16 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  17. Image 17 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  18. Image 18 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  19. Image 19 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  20. Image 20 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  21. Image 21 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  22. Image 22 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  23. Image 23 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  24. Image 24 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  25. Image 25 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  26. Image 26 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  27. Image 27 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  28. Image 28 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  29. Image 29 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  30. Image 30 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  31. Image 31 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  32. Image 32 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  33. Image 33 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  34. Image 34 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  35. Image 35 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  36. Image 36 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  37. Image 37 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  38. Image 38 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  39. Image 39 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  40. Image 40 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  41. Image 41 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  42. Image 42 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  43. Image 43 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  44. Image 44 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  45. Image 45 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  46. Image 46 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  47. Image 47 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  48. Image 48 of 49 For 1231 South Street
  49. Image 49 of 49 For 1231 South Street
Print Flyer
Contact Krista Plagge
Contacting Krista Plagge
  • All fields are required.
Schedule A Showing
Schedule a Showing.
  • All fields are required.
Check this box to Register with us:
Virtual Tour
More Like This
  • MLS#: 612544 ( Single Family )
  • Street Address: 1231 South Street
  • Viewed: 12
  • Price: $3,895,000
  • Price sqft: $1,773
  • Waterfront: No
  • Waterfront Type: None
  • Year Built: 1938
  • Bldg sqft: 2197
  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Total Baths: 3
  • Full Baths: 3
  • Days On Market: 224
  • Additional Information
  • Geolocation: 24.5532 / -81.7871
  • County: MONROE
  • City: KEY WEST
  • Zipcode: 33040
  • Subdivision: Tropical Bldt & Investment Co
  • Provided by: Brenda Donnelly Real Estate LLC
  • Contact: Brenda J Donnelly
  • (305) 304-1116
  • Florida Keys Board of REALTORS
  • DMCA Notice
  • Description
    Newly reimagined, tucked behind a picturesque white picket fence and lush tropical gardens lies, 1231 South Street. Designed to embody the relaxed elegance of the Key West lifestyle, this Conch style retreat is a true sanctuary, featuring a main residence and a completely private guest cottage. Thoughtfully blending modern updates this single story residence invites you to experience the essence of island living. Begin your mornings on the wraparound porch surrounded by vibrant greenery on an 8,500 SQ FT lot, expertly designed by Craig Reynolds landscape architects. This remarkable property features 4 bedrooms and 3 baths, meticulously designed for comfort and style.The spacious (24 x 20') living area features soaring ceilings and abundant natural light are perfect for hosting large gatherings. Throughout the home you will find freshly painted walls.The kitchen and dining room have been repositioned to flow naturally. The kitchen has been newly outfitted with Quartz counters. Maple cabinets, and a Wolf stainless steel gas range complete this space . The expansive primary ensuite bedroom offers a walk in closet, vaulted ceiling, and access to the private outdoor shower. A second ensuite bedroom includes outdoor access, a generous closet, and a unique loft space perfect for additional storage or quiet relaxation. Separate from the home you will find a private one bedroom guest cottage with an additional bath ideal for overnight guests.Outdoors, a free flowing saltwater lagoon pool with a stone waterfall anchors the private oasis, perfect for al fresco dining. The fenced backyard offers ultimate privacy, while the covered patio, complete with ceiling fans and skylights provides a haven for conversations or watching the game. Additional features of this property include 2 private outdoor showers, laundry room, and a custom designed carport.1231 South is located just blocks from White Street's galleries, beaches, Old Town and all Key West has to offer!
Request More Information
  • All fields are required.
Property Location and Similar Properties
All
Similar
Features
Waterfront Description
  1. None
Absolute Longitude
  1. 81.787106
Alternate Key Num
  1. 1042668
Appliances
  1. Washer
  2. Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
  3. Ice Machine
  4. Gas Appliances
  5. Microwave
  6. Oven
  7. Range
  8. Refrigerator
  9. Dishwasher
  10. Dryer
Association Info 1st Right Of Refusal
  1. No
Association Info Association Fee
  1. 0.00
Association Info Mandatory Home Owners Asc
  1. No
Construction
  1. Frame
Cooling
  1. Central Air
  2. Ductless
  3. Attic Fan
  4. Ceiling Fans(s)
Deed Restrictions
  1. Unknown
Dockage
  1. None
Exterior Features
  1. Fencing
  2. Storage
  3. Sprinkler System
  4. Privacy Wall/Fence
  5. Outdoor Shower
  6. Lanai
  7. Lighting
  8. Rain Gutters
  9. Detached Guest Qtrs
Fee Includes
  1. None
Flood Zone
  1. AE
Floor
  1. Wood
Furnished
  1. Negotiable
Gf Interior Features
  1. LED Lighting
Interior Features
  1. Cathedral Ceilings
  2. Window Treatments
  3. Quartz Countertops
  4. Security System
  5. Walk-in Closet(s)
  6. Sky Light(s)
Kw Neighborhood
  1. Midtown West
Legal Description
  1. KW TROPICAL BLDG AND INVESTMENT CO SUB PT LOT 9 & PT LOT 10 & PT LOT 11-12 SQR 8 TR 19 PB1-34 G12-150 OR142-287 OR384-23
Limitd Reprsntation
  1. Yes
Mile Marker
  1. 2.00
Parcel Num
  1. 00042010-000000
Pets
  1. Pets Allowed
Pool Info
  1. In Ground
  2. Concrete
  3. Salt Water
Pool Info Heated
  1. Yes
Porchbalcony
  1. Open Porch/Balcony
Property Group Id
  1. 19990816212109142258000000
Property Type
  1. Single Family
Pub Sewer Hkup
  1. Yes
Rentals Allowed
  1. With Restrictions
Roof
  1. Metal Roof
Shutters
  1. Panel
Side
  1. Median
Sqft Source
  1. Appraisal
Style
  1. Single Family
Tax Year
  1. 2023
Taxes
  1. 20574.76
Utilities
  1. FKAA
  2. Propane
  3. Municipal Sewer
  4. Well
Vehicle Storage
  1. Carport
  2. Off Street Parking
Views
  1. 12
Virtual Tour Url
  1. https://player.vimeo.com/video/1027944937
Water View
  1. No Waterview
Windowsdoors
  1. Other Windows/Doors
  2. Impact Rstnce Window
Year Built
  1. 1938
Zoning
  1. HMDR - Historic Medium Density Residential
Liked Listings
Skip to Main Content
Headshot for Associate Krista Plagge
  1. Krista Plagge, REALTOR ®
  2. Tropic Shores Realty
  3. Mobile: 813.285.1702
  4. krista@homeguidetampa.com